Before you read this, take a look at Matt Conigliaro's Abstract Appeal for a very clear overview of the Terri Schiavo case. I do give a synopsis below, but Matt's done a great job presenting an unbiased view. My viewpoint isn't unbiased. I worked in a nursing home for more than a year, and that has colored my opinion.
In 1990, Terri Schiavo suffered severe brain damage. She does not respond to external stimulus. Her body is alive, but the person that was Terri Schiavo isn't in that body anymore. So severe that more than a dozen doctors that have seen here believe she will remain in the vegetative state she now lives in for the rest of her life. Much of her brain is physically gone - literally gone, not just not functioning, but the flesh has been replaced with spinal fluid.
Terri's husband, Michael, has been trying to do what he believes his wife would want - he's been trying to let her die rather than artificially keeping the body that is shell that used to be her alive.
Her parents are fighting this. They are, of course, grief stricken at their daughter's condition. Their emotional need for her does not give them the right to make this choice for her. They believe she responds to stimulus, but doctors have repeatedly shown that she does not. They want her to respond, so they see her response. I really, really feel for these people, losing a child must be horrible, and they do not want to accept it.
Doctors and judges have agreed on this for over 5 years, but somehow her parents keep managing to get someone else to force this misery on their daughter.
The courts have found that she would not have chosen to live this way. But thanks to the "We know morals better than you" contingent of the Republican party, the
Fate of Terri Schiavo Rests With Judge. Another judge. This time in federal court.
Now the US Congress and President Bush have joined in, forcing Michael to once more plead for his wife.
Not only is their position idiotic, but it's unconstitutional. First, this votes makes it clear, to paraphrase someone I saw on CNN this morning, that these yahoos think they know more about medicine and bioethics than the experts that have already been involved. Second, it's a state matter, and Florida has already decided. Add this to the 2000 election results, and I'm starting to think that Florida has joined D.C. as a fifedom of the US federal government. Third, it's a personal choice, not a governmental choice.
This is a tragic situation. But think on your own life. What would you want? Would you want the government to decide whether you should live or die? In the end, that's the question. I don't want them to decide that, that is my choice. If I don't have the right to decide how to die, how can I have the right to live my life?