In 1993 Congressional Republican's did everything they could to keep the Clinton administration from passing their budget. In the end, Al Gore, as Vice President, had to cast a tie-breaking vote in the Senate.
At the time, Republicans were full of predictions about how bad the economy would suffer.
Said Dick Armey, the House Minority Whip,
It is a recipe for disaster. This plan is not a recipe for more jobs.
New Gingrich, on much the same note, said, the package would lead to "a job killing recession".
There are a lot of similar quotes like that. I won't bore you by listing any more What happened? As has happened time and time again, exactly the opposite of what the tax cutters claim - the economy improved. Not just a little, a lot.
Because of their staunch resistance to the fiscal restraint of the Clinton administration, the Republicans could not accept any credit for the improved economy during those years (which is part of the reason why they changed course and went after Clinton on moral issues rather than economic issues).
Now, in 2009, they are in the same situation. The Republican's, especially those in the House, made a conscious decision to resist Obama's plan. Not due to any belief that stimulus wasn't needed; nope, merely because of their own partisan politics. I mean, heck, it's the largest tax cut ever! When did Republicans start voting against tax cuts?
They voted against the stimulus for purely political reasons. They know that agreeing with Obama will not gain them anything politically, and resisting him might result in political gains. Suspect anyone that gives any other reason for voting against the package.
Arlen Specter, a Republican that voted for the stimulus package, said that several other Republican's congratulated him on his courage voting for the stimulus package. They couldn't because they were worried about the political fall-out for doing the right thing.
That's sad. I hope, just like in 1993, the predictions of the Republicans are wrong. I'm worried, though, that they aren't. Too much is being lost to tax cuts. Too much spending was cut out of the final bill.
The Republicans are putting themselves back into the same spot they were in 1993, but this time, maybe, they may have done enough damage to the package that their hopes come true. I hope not, but the Obama administration, I think, is going to have to get busy and get some more spending packages passed. This package seems too small and too slow.
Recent Comments